Islamic Voice A Monthly English Magazine

June 2009
Cover Page Travelogue Update The Muslim World Current Issues Opinion Editorial Letters Community Round Up Globe Talk from Here & There Face to face Events Voices from the Valley Someone Somewhere Living Islam Reflections Discover Yourself Qur'an Speaks to You Hadith Our Dialogue Book Review Women in Islam Soul Talk Towards Light Matrimonial
ZAKAT Camps/Workshops Jobs Archives Feedback Subscription Links Calendar Contact Us

from Here & There

Iran's Michelle Obama
Tehran:
Rahnavard, 64, holds a PhD in political science and served as an advisor to Khatami, who was president from 1997 to 2005.


Campaigning alongside her husband in the presidential elections, Zahra Rahnavard, the wife of Hossein Mousavi, is seen by many Iranians as the local version of Michelle, the wife of US President Barack Obama.

“We look at her and we say, ‘we want to be like her in the future,’ “ Shakiba Shakerhosseie, one of 12,000 people who recently packed Tehran’s Azadi (Freedom) stadium to hear Rahnavard, told CNN last fortnight. Since her husband unveiled his presidential bid, the mother of three has attended most of his rallies.

In many rallies, the former university chancellor even stole light from her husband Mousavi, a former premier running against incumbent Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and two others in the June 12, polls.

She has given numerous speeches, notably criticizing treatment of women, especially under Ahmadinejad.

This earned her an analogy with Michelle Obama who had contributed to the election of her husband as America’s first-ever black president. “This is the first time after the Revolution we see a lady behind the president,” said Farhad Mahmoudi. “And this is why we’re so happy because we can have a first lady.”

Despite playing a key role in the 1979 Islamic revolution that toppled the US-backed shah, Iranian women have had but a token presence in politics with just a handful of parliament seats and two cabinet posts. Many Iranians have no clues what their presidents’ wives look like.

All Iranian presidents, even reformist Mohammad Khatami, mostly kept their spouses out of the spotlight and shied away from appearing with them at political events or on foreign trips.

Rahnavard, 64, holds a PhD in political science and served as an advisor to Khatami, who was president from 1997 to 2005. She is a Qur’an researcher and authored several books on art and politics. She has long campaigned for the economic empowerment of women and for changing Iran’s laws deemed discriminatory to women.

The grandmother has said that mothering three daughters has made her more sensitive and concerned about women’s issues. Rahnavard, a sculptor and painter, says she enjoys rap music and her favorite accessory is a bohemian handbag adorned with Iranian tribal motifs.

In 2005, shortly after Ahmadinejad’s election, she invited Nobel peace laureate Shirin Ebadi to speak at Tehran’s all-women Al-Zahra university. This angered conservatives who accuse Ebadi of tarnishing the country’s image by her criticism of the human rights situation.

Rahnavard was replaced as university chancellor less than a year later.

“I hope freedom of speech, freedom of the pen and freedom of thought will not be forgotten,” she has told an election rally.


Hobson's choice
By a Staff Writer
In Maharashtra, Muslims votes were taken for granted as they had no option but to vote for the so-called friendly parties like the Congress-NCP regardless of their unfulfilled promises.


In Maharashtra, the Lok Sabha election results show that the Muslim have not been able to develop a political space of their own. The success of the Congress and the Nationalist Congress Party implies that the Muslim votes are divided between these parties.

Muslims make up 10.6 per cent of the State population. Mumbai city has 36.6 per cent Muslims. Suburban Mumbai has about 12.4 per cent, according to Census figures. Over the years, Muslim dissatisfaction has grown, though they have always supported the Congress.

Muslim voters knew very well that they don’t have any options, hence majority of them did not vote. Others deliberately voted for the non-Congress- NCP and non BJP- Sena candidate just taking a wild chance. In the process a substantial number of voters from Mumbai voted for Raj Thackeray-led Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS). The rest surrendered their votes to Congress-NCP because they wanted to defeat BJP-Sena.

Muslims have continued to back the Congress-NCP in, Maharashtra, where parties such as the SP, BSP, Janata Dal-United and the RJD do not have a critical mass.

But ironically Congress- NCP in Maharashtra has become so arrogant and over confident about grabbing Muslim votes that it just conveniently neglected the Muslim leaders’ demand to nominate five Muslim candidates from the constituencies where the community commanded sizeable numbers. They however nominated Abdul Rehman Antulay and Azam Pansare, respectively from Congress and NCP in the general election. Both of them failed in winning the elections resulting in zero Muslim representation from the State. While Antulay was a Minister in the last cabinet, Azam Pansare, a popular NCP leader in the Pune-Pimpri region was instrumental in strengthening the party in that region.

Abu Asim Azmi, the Samajwadi Party’s (SP) Maharashtra president also failed in garnering the sufficient votes in his favour to win the election. The results in Aurangabad and Malegaon, two Muslim dominated towns in Maharashtra are more worrisome. In these towns not only that the Muslim candidates in the fray failed in winning the elections, they also ensured the victory of the candidates from the saffron alliance.

Muslims, by and large, are not impressed by the defeat of the BJP-Sena in Maharashtra. The Muslim electorate is disillusioned by the empty promises of the ruling party and hence has few expectations from the Congress- NCP. Dr Zeenat Shaukatali, professor of Islamic Studies at St. Xaviers College, Mumbai, notes: Though Muslims have matured and have learnt to value their vote, they still follow the trend of voting for the Congress. Though they realise that the Congress is the reason for their backwardness, it is still considered more secular than the others.

The large-scale irregularities in Wakf land into which an inquiry is dragging on since last year, communal riots, and poor implementation of the Srikrishna Commissions report of the 1992-93 Mumbai riots are all festering issues.

However, the larger issues of poverty, lack of opportunities, discrimination and social justice remains a pipedream. A common Muslim in Maharashtra is not impressed by the poll outcome in Maharashtra. The anger against the non performance of Congress-NCP is still very high. May be a substantial Muslim vote may go against Congress-NCP if a credible alternative is in place.

Muslim youth is attracted towards MNS. If Raj Thackeray keep himself away from the BJP and Hindutva politics, the chances of MNS garnering Muslim votes is very high in the Maharashtra Assembly elections due shortly.

If Muslim play MNS card strategically, it will be able to increase its bargaining power with Congress-NCP. The coalition will have no other alternative but to give better representation to Muslim and safeguard their interest.

In the past the Congress used the ‘frightening ploy’ of BJP-Sena emerging victorious to garner their votes. Now is the time for Maharashtra Muslims to revert the ploy against the Congress-NCP as MNS may emerge as a viable alternative in selected pockets.